Carlo'S Bakery Reviews
Rated 4.1 based on 11117 Reviews
Bakeries in New York
625 8th Ave, New York, NY 10018, United States
Published on
January 19, 2024
Last updated
July 10, 2025
Carlo's Bakery maintains a reputable standing particularly appreciated for its quality pastries, cakes, and traditional Italian desserts, with favorable mentions of delectable flavors and craftsmanship. Customer experience reflects a strong satisfaction with the products, especially the signature cannoli and the creatively decorated cakes. The ambiance of the locations contributes positively to the overall visitor satisfaction, adding a warm feel to the indulgent offerings. However, the bakery struggles with operational aspects such as customer service, seating capacity, and amenities like cleanliness and restrooms availability. There are concerns regarding value for money given the high prices, which are often justified by the bakery's association with the 'Cake Boss' fame. Accessibility issues and parking challenges are other pain points mentioned by patrons. Furthermore, inconsistencies in food quality, especially in items like cupcakes and a lobster tail pastry, have been noted, along with service efficiency varying across different visits.
Carlo's Bakery offers a wide variety of pastries and cakes; however, specific options for dietary restrictions such as vegetarian, vegan, or reduced sugar have not been prominently mentioned in customer feedback. We recommend inquiring directly with the bakery for the most accurate information regarding dietary accommodations.
Seating capacity at Carlo's Bakery is often described as limited. Customers should be prepared for potential waiting times for seating, especially during busy hours. In terms of wheelchair accessibility, there have been reports of Carlo's Bakery not being very accommodating in this aspect, although this may vary by location.
Customers commonly acknowledge that while prices at Carlo's Bakery are on the higher end, the quality of the baked goods is believed to justify the cost. However, some patrons have expressed that the high prices, influenced by the bakery's popularity from the 'Cake Boss' TV show, may occasionally be a concern, particularly if they experience any inconsistencies in product quality or service.
"Cake Boss" Buddy Valastro's bakery, known for a variety of cookies, cannoli & elaborate cakes.
