No 53 Frederick Street generally garners positive reviews, indicating a reputable standing within the hospitality sector in Edinburgh. Guests consistently praise the establishment for its prime location, emphasizing easy access to the city's main attractions, and overall cleanliness of the rooms. Comfort is frequently noted due to the quality of the beds, updated bathrooms, and the inclusion of thoughtful amenities like tea and coffee provisions. However, a few issues do mar the customer experience, notably the unreliable WiFi service, and concerns regarding noise disturbances—particularly in rooms near the street or communal areas. The property's communication methods have also received mixed feedback, with one guest experiencing difficulty in conveyance during booking, while another encountered problems with the refund process after a disturbance during their stay.