Featured review

As of Mar 18, 2024, 1323 customers have reviewed this business and rated it 4.5 Star out of 5. The following report provides an in-depth analysis of customer reviews collected.

Link to verified review

Hawksmoor Edinburgh's customer reviews analysis

Hawksmoor Edinburgh garners a robust reputation for its sublime dining environment, set within an aesthetically pleasing and historical building at St Andrews Square. Predominantly, patrons have expressed profound satisfaction with the compelling quality of steaks and the menu's variety, particularly noting the seafood starters as a highlight. While the atmosphere invokes a 1920s aura that captivates customers, the further allure manifests through commendable service from staff members who are described as professional, personable, polite, and particularly knowledgeable about the menu. Despite its higher price point, the consensus underscores that the cost is justified by the excellence of the culinary experience. Nonetheless, isolated feedback indicated desire for more finesse in certain dishes and presentation, highlighting a minor inconsistency with food preparation.

Positive Feedback

Customer testimonials frequently celebrate Hawksmoor Edinburgh's commendable service quality, with staff being lauded for their professionalism, friendliness, and efficiency. The food receives high praise for its flavor and perfection in cooking, especially the steaks and seafood starters. The setting of the restaurant is consistently highlighted for its beautiful and authentic 1920s décor, contributing to what is described as an exceptionally immersive dining experience. Additionally, the restaurant's flexibility with menu options for children and their acknowledgment of special occasions such as birthdays have been positively received, adding a personalized touch to their service.

Concerns and Threads

While feedback for Hawksmoor Edinburgh is overwhelmingly positive, there are some minor critiques that can be distilled from customer reviews. One such aspect is the pricing, which, although generally seen as commensurate with the quality provided, may be perceived as steep for some guests. The ambition in the menu's variety sometimes surpasses execution, leading to occasional lapses in food quality with certain dishes being described as slightly dry or chewy and side dishes like the Caesar salad noted as having too much cheese. Lastly, service, while generally acclaimed, has been occasionally described as stretched thin during busy periods, giving a sense of being rushed rather than relaxed.

Frequently asked questions about Hawksmoor Edinburgh

Does Hawksmoor Edinburgh accommodate children in their dining experience?

Hawksmoor Edinburgh does not feature a specific kids' menu; however, they are accommodating in allowing meals to be shared among children, ensuring a family-friendly dining experience.

What are some of the must-try dishes at Hawksmoor Edinburgh?

Patrons highly recommend trying the steaks for their main course, as they are noted for being cooked to perfection. For starters, seafood options such as the potted beef and bacon, or the scallops with garlic butter, are also praised. Desserts like the sticky toffee pudding are frequently mentioned as standout choices.

Is Hawksmoor Edinburgh suitable for special occasions?

Yes, Hawksmoor Edinburgh is deemed favorable for special occasions. The staff is known for their welcoming approach and for acknowledging celebrations such as birthdays with personalized touches, enhancing the overall dining experience for special events.

Recent customer reviews and testimonials for Hawksmoor Edinburgh

Thomas Elkington

5-Star

3 weeks ago

Absolutely outstanding lunch - service is notably good, very personable and professional. Food is always brilliant, and in a beautiful setting. Salmon to start. Bone-in Rib-eye for main, with all the necessary trimmings. Sticky Toffee for pud.

Sara Lou

5-Star

a month ago

The whole experience was fantastic. First class service, every dish was perfect and delicious I honestly couldn’t fault it. We had the beef and bacon Yorkshire/ crab toast to start and steaks for mains. Steak was first class cooked to perfection and tasted wonderful and all the sides also. The waiter was excellent and yes it very expensive but it was worth it.

Warren Yeung

5-Star

2 months ago

Wonderful experience. Communicated in advance and asked about dining there with two young children. While they don't have a kids menu, there was no problem sharing meals, which they totally lived up to in our experience there. My wife had the Sunday roast which she really enjoyed. My son and I enjoyed a really nice steak, while my youngest was very happy with his makeshift sandwich of bread and bacon. We loved the sticky toffee pudding! Finally, the service was extremely friendly and welcoming. We would be very happy to come again in the future.

Read all reviews

Hawksmoor Edinburgh Reviews Summary

Trustguide Rating

What do customers say about Hawksmoor Edinburgh?

Own this business?

Featured review

Hawksmoor Edinburgh's customer reviews analysis

Positive Feedback

Concerns and Threads

Frequently asked questions about Hawksmoor Edinburgh

Does Hawksmoor Edinburgh accommodate children in their dining experience?

What are some of the must-try dishes at Hawksmoor Edinburgh?

Is Hawksmoor Edinburgh suitable for special occasions?

Recent customer reviews and testimonials for Hawksmoor Edinburgh

Satisfaction Score

Overall Rating

About Hawksmoor Edinburgh