Tamarind Tribeca appears to have a contentious reputation based on the provided customer reviews. While many customers praise the restaurant for its upscale ambiance, refined flavors, and attentive service, there are recurring critiques regarding the flavor profile being tailored more towards the American palate, potentially compromising authenticity. Inconsistencies in the food quality, from blandness to the toughness of meat in certain dishes, often offset the positive dining experience. The price point also appears to be a point of contention, as some guests regard it as high considering their expectations were not met in terms of culinary experience. These reviews depict a dichotomy where customers weigh the environment and service heavily against the actual dishes when determining their overall satisfaction.
Positive feedback for Tamarind Tribeca often highlights the restaurant's upscale ambiance, which provides a beautiful and chic environment for diners. The attentive and spectacular service, particularly during special occasions, is consistently praised. Customers appreciate the variety and flavor of certain signature dishes, such as the Tamarind scallops, Hara bhara kabab, and shrimp caldin, as well as some vegetarian options and desserts like crème brûlée and pistachio kulfi. Food presentation also stands out, noted especially in the context of the upscale dining experience. The restaurant's extensive drink menu, including Indian-style cocktails, is another highlight, with some guests mentioning specific drinks, like the lychee martini, as excellent.
Several reviews indicate key negative aspects impacting the customer experience at Tamarind Tribeca. Multiple diners describe some dishes as lackluster, criticizing the absence of rich flavors and authenticity that would be expected at the establishment's price point. Dishes such as the veg jalfrezi, malai halibut, and chicken tikka masala have been particularly cited for being bland, dry, or tough. Additionally, there are concerns regarding the value for money, with some guests finding the food overpriced given the portion sizes and the perceived quality. Service could also detract from the experience, with reports of it being rushed or not sufficient to counterbalance other deficiencies.
Yes, Tamarind Tribeca has an upscale ambiance and attentive service that many find suitable for celebrations like birthdays and anniversaries.
Tamarind Tribeca provides a selection of vegetarian options and is attentive to dietary restrictions, including gluten-free and various allergens.
Opinions vary regarding portion sizes; some customers find them satisfactory, while others feel they do not offer sufficient value for the cost.
High-end Indian kitchen serving upscale versions of classic dishes in a modern, soaring space.
