The reviews for Duddingston Golf Club present an overwhelmingly positive reputation, primarily highlighting the course's appealing parkland setting, good condition, and the views of Arthur's Seat. Customer experiences seem particularly enhanced by the efficient and cordial service received, both in the pro shop and the clubhouse. The variety of the holes and the course layout have been met with appreciation, noting several features such as streams and challenging greens. Pace of play and maintenance standards also receive commendation, with the excellence of the greens often mentioned. Furthermore, the club's catering services have left a positive impression on visitors, who have praised the quality of food available. However, one review does mention a 'stuffy atmosphere' in the clubhouse, hinting at potential for improvement in the ambiance to cater to a broader range of preferences.